Judge: Protect franchisee against supermarket organization (Coop) as lessor
Does the franchisee need legal protection from supermarket franchisor Coop? The District Court of Rotterdam ruled on 9 February 2018, ECLI:NL:RBROT:2018:1151, that this is the case.
In the event of (premature) termination of the franchise agreement, the rental agreement does not also end automatically. Franchisors often stipulate in their contracts with the franchisee that the duration of the franchise agreement and the lease agreement run synchronously. That provision is in principle invalid.
If a supermarket entrepreneur rents the business space from the franchisor, then the entrepreneur is very dependent on the franchisor. Fortunately, the law has rent protection rules. For example, if the franchise agreement ends, the rental agreement does not also end.
Together with a franchisee, Coop had asked the court for permission to link the duration of the franchise agreement to the duration of the rental agreement. The court makes it clear that the franchisee does not have such a social position compared to Coop. The franchisee requires legal rent protection towards Coop.
It is not the first time that if the franchise agreement ends, the supermarket entrepreneur can operate another formula, despite still renting from the old supermarket organization.
mr. AW Dolphijn – franchise lawyer
Ludwig & Van Dam Franchise attorneys, franchise legal advice. Do you want to respond? Go to dolphijn@ludwigvandam.nl .
Other messages
Attorneys Ludwig & Van Dam look back on transition process C1000
Attorneys Ludwig & Van Dam look back on transition process C1000
Interview Mr. AW Dolphijn and mr. J. Sterk on transition process C1000
Interview Mr. AW Dolphijn and mr. J. Sterk on transition process C1000
Mitigation fine of franchise agreement at supermarket
On 22 April 2015, the East Brabant District Court ruled on a dispute between a franchisee and a franchisor (Emté Franchise BV).
Arbitration clause applicable to franchise agreement? Maybe not
An arbitration clause is occasionally found in franchise agreements.
(Directors’ and shareholders’) liability in the event of transfer or phasing out the franchise formula
(Directors' and shareholders') liability in the event of transfer or phasing out the franchise formula
Directors’ liability in the event of an incorrect forecast
On 4 February 2015, the Rotterdam District Court rendered a judgment on, among other things, the question of whether the director of a selling legal entity was liable.